Repository navigation
feat: DataCollection now gates GraphQL error events, with separate document and variables options - #5934
feat: DataCollection now gates GraphQL error events, with separate document and variables options#5934jamescrosswell wants to merge 11 commits into
Conversation
The GraphQL failed-request handler now reads the resolved DataCollection categories for the bodies it attaches, instead of SendDefaultPii: - The request body is an outgoing request body, so it is attached only when OutgoingRequestBody is collected. Inside it, the `query` (document) and `variables` members are kept or removed according to GraphQLDocument and GraphQLVariables. Batched requests are filtered per request; a body that is not a GraphQL request object is dropped when filtering is needed. - The response body is attached only when IncomingResponseBody is collected. This mirrors sentry-java's Apollo interceptors. Without ConfigureDataCollection every one of these categories falls back to SendDefaultPii, so the output is unchanged. Headers, cookies and the URL stay on SendDefaultPii until the shared accessors from #5429 land. Refs #5432 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…' into ai/dc-5432-graphql-5177a5
…ollection Uses the shared accessors from #5429, the same way SentryHttpFailedRequestHandler does: headers go through RequestHeadersWithLegacyPiiGate and ResponseHeadersWithLegacyPiiGate, cookies through Cookies, and Request.Url and Request.QueryString through UrlQueryParams. Response cookies now come from Set-Cookie, which responses send, rather than Cookie. Request.Url keeps the same SendDefaultPii split for user:pass@ and #fragment as the HTTP handler. Refs #5432 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…' into ai/dc-5432-graphql-5177a5
Codecov Report❌ Patch coverage is
Additional details and impacted files@@ Coverage Diff @@
## ai/dc-5429-failed-request-0ffcba #5934 +/- ##
====================================================================
- Coverage 77.75% 77.61% -0.15%
====================================================================
Files 535 546 +11
Lines 19766 20128 +362
Branches 3952 3989 +37
====================================================================
+ Hits 15370 15623 +253
- Misses 3544 3647 +103
- Partials 852 858 +6 ☔ View full report in Codecov by Harness. 🚀 New features to boost your workflow:
|
…' into ai/dc-5432-graphql-5177a5
…' into ai/dc-5432-graphql-5177a5
…' into ai/dc-5432-graphql-5177a5
…' into ai/dc-5432-graphql-5177a5
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Good to approve, with optional comments
Closes #5432 as scoped: the GraphQL failed-request handler now reads every field from DataCollectionResolver, the legacy bridge keeps today's SendDefaultPii output, and GraphQL.Document / GraphQL.Variables filter the request body inside the OutgoingRequestBody gate. Tests cover the bridge, every document/variables combination, the body-type gates, batched bodies and malformed input.
- Optional:
GraphQL.Variables = falsedoesn't fully keep variable values out of the event. The exception message iserrors[0].message(src/Sentry/SentryGraphQLHttpFailedRequestHandler.cs, around line 35), andResponse.Datais gated only onIncomingResponseBody. Many servers echo bad variable values in error messages, for example graphql-js'sVariable "$id" got invalid value .... This was already true before this PR. A sentence in theGraphQLOptions.VariablesXML doc would set the right expectation. - Optional: when one GraphQL gate is off,
FilterRequestContent(src/Sentry/GraphQLRequestContent.cs) drops any body that isn't a JSON object or array, such as multipart upload requests, and logs nothing. Dropping it is the safe default, but aLogDebugthere would explain a missingRequest.Data. - Optional: variable values that are collected are attached raw, without the key-based denylist in
SensitiveDataFilter, so a variable namedpasswordis sent as-is. This matches the previousSendDefaultPii = truebehaviour, so a follow-up is fine if scrubbing is wanted.
This is an automated preliminary review.
…riables doesn't cover FilterRequestContent now logs at debug level when it drops a body it can't filter, so a missing Request.Data has an explanation. The GraphQLOptions.Variables doc notes that variable values echoed in server error messages and response bodies aren't filtered. Refs #5432 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
Following up on the automated review:
|
Part of #5420 (Phase 2). Moves
SentryGraphQLHttpFailedRequestHandlerfromSendDefaultPiito the resolved DataCollection categories. WithoutConfigureDataCollection, every category falls back toSendDefaultPii, so bodies, headers and cookies come out as they do today. The exceptions are response cookies and the URL, both under "Worth flagging".What each field reads now
Request.Data(GraphQL request body)SendDefaultPiiOutgoingRequestBody, then thequery/variablesmembers kept or removed byGraphQL.Document/GraphQL.VariablesResponse.DataSendDefaultPiiIncomingResponseBodySendDefaultPiiRequestHeadersWithLegacyPiiGate/ResponseHeadersWithLegacyPiiGateRequest.Cookies/Response.CookiesSendDefaultPiiCookies. Response cookies now come fromSet-CookieRequest.Url/Request.QueryStringqueryUrlQueryParamsRequest.Urlcredentials and fragmentSendDefaultPiiRequest.FragmentwhenSendDefaultPiiis on or DataCollection is configuredHow the GraphQL categories combine with
httpBodiesThe handler attaches the raw HTTP request body, so that body is an outgoing request body first and a GraphQL document second. Both gates have to allow it:
OutgoingRequestBodydecides whether any request body is attached.FilterRequestContentremovesquerywhenGraphQL.Documentis off andvariableswhenGraphQL.Variablesis off. With both off it attaches nothing. Batched requests (a JSON array) are filtered per request. If a filter is needed and the body isn't a GraphQL request object, it is dropped instead of being sent unfiltered.This matches sentry-java's Apollo interceptors, the client-side counterpart to this handler:
isOutgoingRequestBody, thenGraphqlUtils.filterRequestBody. Java'sisGraphqlDocumentWithLegacyBodyGate()belongs to its server-side graphql-java reporter, which has no HTTP body. In .NET,GraphQLDocument/GraphQLVariablesalready fall back toSendDefaultPii, which is exactly what gated this body, so the resolver needs no new GraphQL accessor. Under the bridge, both gates areSendDefaultPiiand the body comes through byte-for-byte as before. Unlike the JS SDK, the bridge mapsSendDefaultPii = falseto "GraphQL off", because this handler never attached the document without it.The response body carries
dataanderrors, not the document or variables, so onlyIncomingResponseBodygates it.Worth flagging
Set-Cookie. The handler used to readCookiefrom the response, a header responses don't send, soResponse.Cookieswas always empty in practice. This follows DataCollection phase 2: migrate redact cascade and HTTP failed-request handler #5429's change to the HTTP handler;HandleResponse_Error_FiltersCookiesnow usesSet-Cookie.user:pass@and the fragment no longer reachRequest.Url, even withSendDefaultPii = true. This applies the decision recorded on DataCollection phase 2: migrate redact cascade and HTTP failed-request handler #5429 (DataCollection phase 2: migrate redact cascade and HTTP failed-request handler #5429 (comment)) verbatim, matching sentry-java and sentry-python. The fragment moves to the newSentryRequest.Fragment, through fix: always filter credentials from URLs, and apply DataCollection to failed HTTP request events #5935'sUrlFragmentWithLegacyPiiGate. So it's still left out withSendDefaultPii = false, as before, and once DataCollection is configured it's always sent, as in Java, Python and JS. We also always redact fragments in case these contain sensitive data.Closes #5432
🤖 Generated with Claude Code